A Road to Conflict

Stakeholder’s and Social Network Analysis of the Media Portrayals of a Social-Environmental Conflict in Bolivia

Victoria Reyes-García, Oriol Andrés-Conejero, Alvaro Fernandez-Llamazares Onrubia, Isabel Diaz-Reviriego, José Luis Molina

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Society's understanding of a conflict is mediated by information provided in mass media, for which researchers stress the importance of analyzing media portrays of stakeholders in a conflict. We analyze information from the Bolivian press regarding the construction of a road crossing the Isiboro-Secure Indigenous Territory and National Park (TIPNIS). Using stakeholder's and social network analyses, we explore stakeholder's positions and alliances as represented in the media and contrast it with previous scholarly work. We found that some actors cited as central in scholar analyses of the conflict are largely absent in the media (e.g., private investors, conservationist sector) and that the media tend to present stakeholders as having more homogeneous positions than the academic literature does while also neglecting some important alliances in their account. The media also suggests that Indigenous communities are forging stronger alliances with urban sectors and civil society, alliances not stressed by researchers.

Original languageEnglish
JournalSociety and Natural Resources
Volume32
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)452-472
Number of pages21
ISSN0894-1920
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2019
MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

Fields of Science

  • 1172 Environmental sciences
  • indigenous peoples
  • Isiboro-Secure Indigenous Territory and National Park
  • social movements
  • social network analysis
  • social-environmental conflict
  • stakeholder analysis
  • climate-change
  • coverage
  • gender
  • bias
  • infrastructure
  • governance
  • resistance
  • frontiers
  • politics
  • events

Cite this

Reyes-García, Victoria ; Andrés-Conejero, Oriol ; Fernandez-Llamazares Onrubia, Alvaro ; Diaz-Reviriego, Isabel ; Molina, José Luis. / A Road to Conflict : Stakeholder’s and Social Network Analysis of the Media Portrayals of a Social-Environmental Conflict in Bolivia. In: Society and Natural Resources. 2019 ; Vol. 32, No. 4. pp. 452-472 .
@article{40d364eec3824efd973b76969a11a6ea,
title = "A Road to Conflict: Stakeholder’s and Social Network Analysis of the Media Portrayals of a Social-Environmental Conflict in Bolivia",
abstract = "Society's understanding of a conflict is mediated by information provided in mass media, for which researchers stress the importance of analyzing media portrays of stakeholders in a conflict. We analyze information from the Bolivian press regarding the construction of a road crossing the Isiboro-Secure Indigenous Territory and National Park (TIPNIS). Using stakeholder's and social network analyses, we explore stakeholder's positions and alliances as represented in the media and contrast it with previous scholarly work. We found that some actors cited as central in scholar analyses of the conflict are largely absent in the media (e.g., private investors, conservationist sector) and that the media tend to present stakeholders as having more homogeneous positions than the academic literature does while also neglecting some important alliances in their account. The media also suggests that Indigenous communities are forging stronger alliances with urban sectors and civil society, alliances not stressed by researchers.",
keywords = "1172 Environmental sciences, indigenous peoples, Isiboro-Secure Indigenous Territory and National Park, social movements, social network analysis, social-environmental conflict, stakeholder analysis, climate-change, coverage, gender, bias, infrastructure, governance, resistance, frontiers, politics, events",
author = "Victoria Reyes-Garc{\'i}a and Oriol Andr{\'e}s-Conejero and {Fernandez-Llamazares Onrubia}, Alvaro and Isabel Diaz-Reviriego and Molina, {Jos{\'e} Luis}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1080/08941920.2018.1539199",
language = "English",
volume = "32",
pages = "452--472",
journal = "Society and Natural Resources",
issn = "0894-1920",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "4",

}

A Road to Conflict : Stakeholder’s and Social Network Analysis of the Media Portrayals of a Social-Environmental Conflict in Bolivia. / Reyes-García, Victoria; Andrés-Conejero, Oriol; Fernandez-Llamazares Onrubia, Alvaro; Diaz-Reviriego, Isabel; Molina, José Luis.

In: Society and Natural Resources, Vol. 32, No. 4, 01.2019, p. 452-472 .

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - A Road to Conflict

T2 - Stakeholder’s and Social Network Analysis of the Media Portrayals of a Social-Environmental Conflict in Bolivia

AU - Reyes-García, Victoria

AU - Andrés-Conejero, Oriol

AU - Fernandez-Llamazares Onrubia, Alvaro

AU - Diaz-Reviriego, Isabel

AU - Molina, José Luis

PY - 2019/1

Y1 - 2019/1

N2 - Society's understanding of a conflict is mediated by information provided in mass media, for which researchers stress the importance of analyzing media portrays of stakeholders in a conflict. We analyze information from the Bolivian press regarding the construction of a road crossing the Isiboro-Secure Indigenous Territory and National Park (TIPNIS). Using stakeholder's and social network analyses, we explore stakeholder's positions and alliances as represented in the media and contrast it with previous scholarly work. We found that some actors cited as central in scholar analyses of the conflict are largely absent in the media (e.g., private investors, conservationist sector) and that the media tend to present stakeholders as having more homogeneous positions than the academic literature does while also neglecting some important alliances in their account. The media also suggests that Indigenous communities are forging stronger alliances with urban sectors and civil society, alliances not stressed by researchers.

AB - Society's understanding of a conflict is mediated by information provided in mass media, for which researchers stress the importance of analyzing media portrays of stakeholders in a conflict. We analyze information from the Bolivian press regarding the construction of a road crossing the Isiboro-Secure Indigenous Territory and National Park (TIPNIS). Using stakeholder's and social network analyses, we explore stakeholder's positions and alliances as represented in the media and contrast it with previous scholarly work. We found that some actors cited as central in scholar analyses of the conflict are largely absent in the media (e.g., private investors, conservationist sector) and that the media tend to present stakeholders as having more homogeneous positions than the academic literature does while also neglecting some important alliances in their account. The media also suggests that Indigenous communities are forging stronger alliances with urban sectors and civil society, alliances not stressed by researchers.

KW - 1172 Environmental sciences

KW - indigenous peoples

KW - Isiboro-Secure Indigenous Territory and National Park

KW - social movements

KW - social network analysis

KW - social-environmental conflict

KW - stakeholder analysis

KW - climate-change

KW - coverage

KW - gender

KW - bias

KW - infrastructure

KW - governance

KW - resistance

KW - frontiers

KW - politics

KW - events

U2 - 10.1080/08941920.2018.1539199

DO - 10.1080/08941920.2018.1539199

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - 452

EP - 472

JO - Society and Natural Resources

JF - Society and Natural Resources

SN - 0894-1920

IS - 4

ER -