Social service professional or market expert?

: maternity care relations under neoliberal healthcare reform

Jane Sandall, Cecilia Benoit, Sirpa Wrede, Susan F Murray, Edwin R van Teijlingen, Rachel Westfall

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    Abstract

    Recent developments in the organization and practice of healthcare, driven by the introduction of (quasi-) markets and privatization, are altering traditional forms of professionalism found in high- and middle-income countries. Yet there remains debate about whether these neoliberal trends are universal or country specific, and whether they have any effect (positive or negative) on health service delivery. This article develops a comparative analysis that focuses on changes in maternity service systems in four countries in Northern Europe and the Americas with primarily publicly financed healthcare systems: the UK, Finland, Chile and Canada. The article begins with a discussion of the continuum of professional forms found in the post-Second World War period and their relationship to different kinds of welfare states. It then focuses on the impact of recent neoliberal reforms on the ideological projects of the medical and allied health professions in the four case examples. The results show that variation across time and place is mainly the result of structural/economic factors and that various forms of professional discourses are the result of the public/private ways that healthcare systems are organized. The article concludes with suggestions for further comparative sociological research.
    Original languageEnglish
    JournalCurrent Sociology
    Volume57
    Issue number4
    Pages (from-to)529-553
    Number of pages25
    ISSN0011-3921
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2009
    MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

    Fields of Science

    • mödravård
    • professioner
    • vårdarbete
    • äityishuolto
    • professiot
    • hoitotyö

    Cite this

    Sandall, Jane ; Benoit, Cecilia ; Wrede, Sirpa ; Murray, Susan F ; van Teijlingen, Edwin R ; Westfall, Rachel. / Social service professional or market expert? : maternity care relations under neoliberal healthcare reform. In: Current Sociology. 2009 ; Vol. 57, No. 4. pp. 529-553.
    @article{9ea7b9aade7349829480be519b3c6b7d,
    title = "Social service professional or market expert?: : maternity care relations under neoliberal healthcare reform",
    abstract = "Recent developments in the organization and practice of healthcare, driven by the introduction of (quasi-) markets and privatization, are altering traditional forms of professionalism found in high- and middle-income countries. Yet there remains debate about whether these neoliberal trends are universal or country specific, and whether they have any effect (positive or negative) on health service delivery. This article develops a comparative analysis that focuses on changes in maternity service systems in four countries in Northern Europe and the Americas with primarily publicly financed healthcare systems: the UK, Finland, Chile and Canada. The article begins with a discussion of the continuum of professional forms found in the post-Second World War period and their relationship to different kinds of welfare states. It then focuses on the impact of recent neoliberal reforms on the ideological projects of the medical and allied health professions in the four case examples. The results show that variation across time and place is mainly the result of structural/economic factors and that various forms of professional discourses are the result of the public/private ways that healthcare systems are organized. The article concludes with suggestions for further comparative sociological research.",
    keywords = "m{\"o}drav{\aa}rd, professioner, v{\aa}rdarbete, {\"a}ityishuolto, professiot, hoitoty{\"o}, m{\"o}drav{\aa}rd, professioner, v{\aa}rdarbete, {\"a}ityishuolto, professiot, hoitoty{\"o}, m{\"o}drav{\aa}rd, professioner, v{\aa}rdarbete, {\"a}ityishuolto, professiot, hoitoty{\"o}",
    author = "Jane Sandall and Cecilia Benoit and Sirpa Wrede and Murray, {Susan F} and {van Teijlingen}, {Edwin R} and Rachel Westfall",
    year = "2009",
    doi = "10.1177/0011392109104353",
    language = "English",
    volume = "57",
    pages = "529--553",
    journal = "Current Sociology",
    issn = "0011-3921",
    publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd STM",
    number = "4",

    }

    Social service professional or market expert? : maternity care relations under neoliberal healthcare reform. / Sandall, Jane; Benoit, Cecilia; Wrede, Sirpa; Murray, Susan F; van Teijlingen, Edwin R; Westfall, Rachel.

    In: Current Sociology, Vol. 57, No. 4, 2009, p. 529-553.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Social service professional or market expert?

    T2 - : maternity care relations under neoliberal healthcare reform

    AU - Sandall, Jane

    AU - Benoit, Cecilia

    AU - Wrede, Sirpa

    AU - Murray, Susan F

    AU - van Teijlingen, Edwin R

    AU - Westfall, Rachel

    PY - 2009

    Y1 - 2009

    N2 - Recent developments in the organization and practice of healthcare, driven by the introduction of (quasi-) markets and privatization, are altering traditional forms of professionalism found in high- and middle-income countries. Yet there remains debate about whether these neoliberal trends are universal or country specific, and whether they have any effect (positive or negative) on health service delivery. This article develops a comparative analysis that focuses on changes in maternity service systems in four countries in Northern Europe and the Americas with primarily publicly financed healthcare systems: the UK, Finland, Chile and Canada. The article begins with a discussion of the continuum of professional forms found in the post-Second World War period and their relationship to different kinds of welfare states. It then focuses on the impact of recent neoliberal reforms on the ideological projects of the medical and allied health professions in the four case examples. The results show that variation across time and place is mainly the result of structural/economic factors and that various forms of professional discourses are the result of the public/private ways that healthcare systems are organized. The article concludes with suggestions for further comparative sociological research.

    AB - Recent developments in the organization and practice of healthcare, driven by the introduction of (quasi-) markets and privatization, are altering traditional forms of professionalism found in high- and middle-income countries. Yet there remains debate about whether these neoliberal trends are universal or country specific, and whether they have any effect (positive or negative) on health service delivery. This article develops a comparative analysis that focuses on changes in maternity service systems in four countries in Northern Europe and the Americas with primarily publicly financed healthcare systems: the UK, Finland, Chile and Canada. The article begins with a discussion of the continuum of professional forms found in the post-Second World War period and their relationship to different kinds of welfare states. It then focuses on the impact of recent neoliberal reforms on the ideological projects of the medical and allied health professions in the four case examples. The results show that variation across time and place is mainly the result of structural/economic factors and that various forms of professional discourses are the result of the public/private ways that healthcare systems are organized. The article concludes with suggestions for further comparative sociological research.

    KW - mödravård

    KW - professioner

    KW - vårdarbete

    KW - äityishuolto

    KW - professiot

    KW - hoitotyö

    KW - mödravård

    KW - professioner

    KW - vårdarbete

    KW - äityishuolto

    KW - professiot

    KW - hoitotyö

    KW - mödravård

    KW - professioner

    KW - vårdarbete

    KW - äityishuolto

    KW - professiot

    KW - hoitotyö

    U2 - 10.1177/0011392109104353

    DO - 10.1177/0011392109104353

    M3 - Article

    VL - 57

    SP - 529

    EP - 553

    JO - Current Sociology

    JF - Current Sociology

    SN - 0011-3921

    IS - 4

    ER -