Emotional Dynamics of Right- and Left-Wing Political Populism

Mikko Erkki Matias Salmela, Christian von Scheve

    Tutkimustuotos: ArtikkelijulkaisuArtikkeliTieteellinenvertaisarvioitu

    Kuvaus

    Emotions are prevalent in the rhetoric of populist politicians and among their electorate. We argue that partially dissimilar emotional processes may be driving right- and left-wing populism. Existing research has associated populism with fear and insecurities experienced in contemporary societies on the one hand, and with anger, resentment, and hatred on the other. Yet, there are significant differences in the targets of right- and left-wing resentment: a political and economic establishment deemed responsible for austerity politics (left), and political and cultural elites accused of favoring ethnic, religious, and sexual outgroups at the expense of the neglected ingroup (right). Referring to partially different emotional opportunity structures and distinct political strategies at exploiting these structures, we suggest that right-wing populism is characterized by repressed shame that transforms fear and insecurity into anger, resentment, and hatred against perceived “enemies” of the precarious self. Left-wing populism, in turn, associates more with acknowledged shame that allows individuals to self-identify as aggrieved and humiliated by neoliberal policies and their advocates. The latter type of shame holds emancipatory potential as it allows individuals to establish bonds with others who feel the same, whereas repressors remain in their shame or seek bonds from repression-mediated defensive anger and hatred.
    Alkuperäiskielienglanti
    LehtiHumanity & Society
    Vuosikerta42
    Numero4
    Sivut434-454
    Sivumäärä21
    ISSN0160-5976
    DOI - pysyväislinkit
    TilaJulkaistu - 24 syyskuuta 2018
    OKM-julkaisutyyppiA1 Alkuperäisartikkeli tieteellisessä aikakauslehdessä, vertaisarvioitu

    Tieteenalat

    • 5141 Sosiologia
    • 611 Filosofia
    • 517 Valtio-oppi, hallintotiede

    Lainaa tätä

    Salmela, Mikko Erkki Matias ; von Scheve, Christian. / Emotional Dynamics of Right- and Left-Wing Political Populism. Julkaisussa: Humanity & Society. 2018 ; Vuosikerta 42, Nro 4. Sivut 434-454 .
    @article{b1e4eeae5d984b49874b3f3ea28abbd3,
    title = "Emotional Dynamics of Right- and Left-Wing Political Populism",
    abstract = "Emotions are prevalent in the rhetoric of populist politicians and among their electorate. We argue that partially dissimilar emotional processes may be driving right- and left-wing populism. Existing research has associated populism with fear and insecurities experienced in contemporary societies on the one hand, and with anger, resentment, and hatred on the other. Yet, there are significant differences in the targets of right- and left-wing resentment: a political and economic establishment deemed responsible for austerity politics (left), and political and cultural elites accused of favoring ethnic, religious, and sexual outgroups at the expense of the neglected ingroup (right). Referring to partially different emotional opportunity structures and distinct political strategies at exploiting these structures, we suggest that right-wing populism is characterized by repressed shame that transforms fear and insecurity into anger, resentment, and hatred against perceived “enemies” of the precarious self. Left-wing populism, in turn, associates more with acknowledged shame that allows individuals to self-identify as aggrieved and humiliated by neoliberal policies and their advocates. The latter type of shame holds emancipatory potential as it allows individuals to establish bonds with others who feel the same, whereas repressors remain in their shame or seek bonds from repression-mediated defensive anger and hatred.",
    keywords = "5141 Sociology, 611 Philosophy, 517 Political science",
    author = "Salmela, {Mikko Erkki Matias} and {von Scheve}, Christian",
    year = "2018",
    month = "9",
    day = "24",
    doi = "10.1177/0160597618802521",
    language = "English",
    volume = "42",
    pages = "434--454",
    journal = "Humanity & Society",
    issn = "0160-5976",
    publisher = "Association for Humanist Sociology",
    number = "4",

    }

    Emotional Dynamics of Right- and Left-Wing Political Populism. / Salmela, Mikko Erkki Matias; von Scheve, Christian.

    julkaisussa: Humanity & Society, Vuosikerta 42, Nro 4, 24.09.2018, s. 434-454 .

    Tutkimustuotos: ArtikkelijulkaisuArtikkeliTieteellinenvertaisarvioitu

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Emotional Dynamics of Right- and Left-Wing Political Populism

    AU - Salmela, Mikko Erkki Matias

    AU - von Scheve, Christian

    PY - 2018/9/24

    Y1 - 2018/9/24

    N2 - Emotions are prevalent in the rhetoric of populist politicians and among their electorate. We argue that partially dissimilar emotional processes may be driving right- and left-wing populism. Existing research has associated populism with fear and insecurities experienced in contemporary societies on the one hand, and with anger, resentment, and hatred on the other. Yet, there are significant differences in the targets of right- and left-wing resentment: a political and economic establishment deemed responsible for austerity politics (left), and political and cultural elites accused of favoring ethnic, religious, and sexual outgroups at the expense of the neglected ingroup (right). Referring to partially different emotional opportunity structures and distinct political strategies at exploiting these structures, we suggest that right-wing populism is characterized by repressed shame that transforms fear and insecurity into anger, resentment, and hatred against perceived “enemies” of the precarious self. Left-wing populism, in turn, associates more with acknowledged shame that allows individuals to self-identify as aggrieved and humiliated by neoliberal policies and their advocates. The latter type of shame holds emancipatory potential as it allows individuals to establish bonds with others who feel the same, whereas repressors remain in their shame or seek bonds from repression-mediated defensive anger and hatred.

    AB - Emotions are prevalent in the rhetoric of populist politicians and among their electorate. We argue that partially dissimilar emotional processes may be driving right- and left-wing populism. Existing research has associated populism with fear and insecurities experienced in contemporary societies on the one hand, and with anger, resentment, and hatred on the other. Yet, there are significant differences in the targets of right- and left-wing resentment: a political and economic establishment deemed responsible for austerity politics (left), and political and cultural elites accused of favoring ethnic, religious, and sexual outgroups at the expense of the neglected ingroup (right). Referring to partially different emotional opportunity structures and distinct political strategies at exploiting these structures, we suggest that right-wing populism is characterized by repressed shame that transforms fear and insecurity into anger, resentment, and hatred against perceived “enemies” of the precarious self. Left-wing populism, in turn, associates more with acknowledged shame that allows individuals to self-identify as aggrieved and humiliated by neoliberal policies and their advocates. The latter type of shame holds emancipatory potential as it allows individuals to establish bonds with others who feel the same, whereas repressors remain in their shame or seek bonds from repression-mediated defensive anger and hatred.

    KW - 5141 Sociology

    KW - 611 Philosophy

    KW - 517 Political science

    U2 - 10.1177/0160597618802521

    DO - 10.1177/0160597618802521

    M3 - Article

    VL - 42

    SP - 434

    EP - 454

    JO - Humanity & Society

    JF - Humanity & Society

    SN - 0160-5976

    IS - 4

    ER -