A Legitimacy-based Approach to EU Criminal Law: Maybe We Are Getting There, After All

Forskningsoutput: TidskriftsbidragArtikelVetenskapligPeer review

Sammanfattning

European Union (EU) law is known for its strong emphasis on effectivity and more generally for its instrumental character. This is not foreign even to European criminal law, a feature which creates some tension between the EU criminal law and criminal law in the national setting. EU Framework Decisions and Directives often require the Member States to criminalize certain forms of conduct with sanctions that are ‘Effective, Dissuasive and Proportionate’. In this article, I try to show that it would be timely to look at EU criminal law from an alternative point of view, as a more mature law. I call this a legitimacy-based approach. Such a reading would ease some of these tensions. It would also be helpful in developing a criminal policy for the EU, a policy which would be realistic and pragmatic. And it would be easier to look at EU criminal law from the point of view of justice. In order to get there, we need to see where the (current) narrow deterrence argument gets is wrong or one-sided. Some social theory is needed in order to make the point.
Originalspråkengelska
TidskriftNew Journal of European Criminal Law
Volym11
Utgåva1
Sidor (från-till)20-39
Antal sidor19
ISSN2032-2844
DOI
StatusPublicerad - 1 mar 2020
MoE-publikationstypA1 Tidskriftsartikel-refererad

Vetenskapsgrenar

  • 513 Juridik

Citera det här

@article{bea3a6d4fb204bf29eef1a83d1de10a0,
title = "A Legitimacy-based Approach to EU Criminal Law:: Maybe We Are Getting There, After All",
abstract = "European Union (EU) law is known for its strong emphasis on effectivity and more generally for its instrumental character. This is not foreign even to European criminal law, a feature which creates some tension between the EU criminal law and criminal law in the national setting. EU Framework Decisions and Directives often require the Member States to criminalize certain forms of conduct with sanctions that are ‘Effective, Dissuasive and Proportionate’. In this article, I try to show that it would be timely to look at EU criminal law from an alternative point of view, as a more mature law. I call this a legitimacy-based approach. Such a reading would ease some of these tensions. It would also be helpful in developing a criminal policy for the EU, a policy which would be realistic and pragmatic. And it would be easier to look at EU criminal law from the point of view of justice. In order to get there, we need to see where the (current) narrow deterrence argument gets is wrong or one-sided. Some social theory is needed in order to make the point.",
keywords = "513 Law",
author = "Kimmo Nuotio",
year = "2020",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/2032284420903386",
language = "English",
volume = "11",
pages = "20--39",
journal = "New Journal of European Criminal Law",
issn = "2032-2844",
publisher = "Intersentia",
number = "1",

}

A Legitimacy-based Approach to EU Criminal Law: Maybe We Are Getting There, After All. / Nuotio, Kimmo.

I: New Journal of European Criminal Law, Vol. 11, Nr. 1, 01.03.2020, s. 20-39.

Forskningsoutput: TidskriftsbidragArtikelVetenskapligPeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - A Legitimacy-based Approach to EU Criminal Law:

T2 - Maybe We Are Getting There, After All

AU - Nuotio, Kimmo

PY - 2020/3/1

Y1 - 2020/3/1

N2 - European Union (EU) law is known for its strong emphasis on effectivity and more generally for its instrumental character. This is not foreign even to European criminal law, a feature which creates some tension between the EU criminal law and criminal law in the national setting. EU Framework Decisions and Directives often require the Member States to criminalize certain forms of conduct with sanctions that are ‘Effective, Dissuasive and Proportionate’. In this article, I try to show that it would be timely to look at EU criminal law from an alternative point of view, as a more mature law. I call this a legitimacy-based approach. Such a reading would ease some of these tensions. It would also be helpful in developing a criminal policy for the EU, a policy which would be realistic and pragmatic. And it would be easier to look at EU criminal law from the point of view of justice. In order to get there, we need to see where the (current) narrow deterrence argument gets is wrong or one-sided. Some social theory is needed in order to make the point.

AB - European Union (EU) law is known for its strong emphasis on effectivity and more generally for its instrumental character. This is not foreign even to European criminal law, a feature which creates some tension between the EU criminal law and criminal law in the national setting. EU Framework Decisions and Directives often require the Member States to criminalize certain forms of conduct with sanctions that are ‘Effective, Dissuasive and Proportionate’. In this article, I try to show that it would be timely to look at EU criminal law from an alternative point of view, as a more mature law. I call this a legitimacy-based approach. Such a reading would ease some of these tensions. It would also be helpful in developing a criminal policy for the EU, a policy which would be realistic and pragmatic. And it would be easier to look at EU criminal law from the point of view of justice. In order to get there, we need to see where the (current) narrow deterrence argument gets is wrong or one-sided. Some social theory is needed in order to make the point.

KW - 513 Law

U2 - 10.1177/2032284420903386

DO - 10.1177/2032284420903386

M3 - Article

VL - 11

SP - 20

EP - 39

JO - New Journal of European Criminal Law

JF - New Journal of European Criminal Law

SN - 2032-2844

IS - 1

ER -